Space Law

Who Owns the Moon? The Legal Story of the Next Frontier

Or-Hof Law | Space Law

Dan Or-Hof teaches the Space Law course at Reichman University’s Harry Radzyner Law School. In this article, drawing on his lecture on international space law, we explore a field where questions of sovereignty, ownership and responsibility reach far beyond Earth.

On 4 October 1957, a small satellite entered orbit around Earth – and challenged not only the balance of power between nations, but also the law. Sputnik 1 passed over countries without seeking permission. On the ground, borders were clear. Above them, a new reality was unfolding, without a dedicated treaty to govern it.

The most fascinating part of the story is what did not happen: no State protested that orbital overflight violated its sovereignty. That silence became a milestone in the emergence of the customary rule allowing satellites to orbit above national territories. Sometimes, a new legal rule begins not with a signature, but with the absence of an objection.

A Flag on the Moon Is Not a Title Deed

In July 1969, American astronauts planted a flag on the Moon. The image became a historic symbol, but not a certificate of ownership. Later that year, Congress made clear in legislation that the flag was a gesture of national pride, not a declaration of sovereignty.

The distinction rests on the 1967 Outer Space Treaty. Article II prohibits national appropriation of outer space, including the Moon and other celestial bodies, by claims of sovereignty, use, occupation or any other means. Put simply, arriving first does not give a State ownership.

What about a private individual? Since 1980, American entrepreneur Dennis Hope has sold “plots” on the Moon, arguing that the prohibition applies to States, not individuals. The prevailing legal view rejects that argument: private title requires recognition and enforcement, and a State Who cannot circumvent the prohibition on appropriation by recognizing a private claim to lunar territory. An impressive certificate does not turn lunar land into legally recognized property.

If No One Owns the Moon, Who Owns Its Resources?

This is where the story becomes more complicated. The question is no longer just who may plant a flag, but whether a company can extract lunar water ice and own what it extracts. Is mining a permitted use – or prohibited appropriation?

One approach borrows an analogy from the sea: you cannot own the high seas, but you can own the fish you catch. Several States have adopted national laws, including the United States (2015), Luxembourg (2017), the UAE (2019) and Japan (2021), distinguishing ownership of a celestial body from ownership of an extracted resource. The Artemis Accords, a set of non-binding political commitments that Israel signed in January 2022, also affirm that extracting and using space resources does not inherently constitute national appropriation. This is an important position in the debate, not a universally agreed legal solution.

In December 2020, NASA gave this question a tangible form: it contracted with companies to purchase small quantities of material to be collected on the Moon. One contract set a symbolic price of just one US dollar. The significance lay not in the price, but in the legal proposition: transferring ownership of a resource collected on the Moon without first bringing it back to Earth.

The Space Race Is Also a Race to Shape the Rules

Near the Moon’s south pole, permanently shadowed craters may contain water ice. When several actors seek to operate at the same desirable sites, freedom of access can collide with the need to protect existing operations.

Imagine, by way of illustration, two operators seeking to work near the same crater: one needs to land equipment, while the other fears the landing will damage its facilities. Must the first keep its distance? Who decides how far away, and for how long? This hypothetical captures the tension behind the Artemis Accords’ “safety zones”: coordination to prevent harmful interference on the one hand, and concern that protecting operations could effectively exclude others from a valuable site on the other.

Article IX of the Outer Space Treaty requires due regard for the corresponding interests of other States and includes obligations concerning harmful contamination and prior consultation where a State has reason to believe its activity may cause potentially harmful interference. It does not give another State a veto. The challenge is turning broad principles into workable rules – even when the participants are competitors.

Why This Matters to Israeli Companies

Space is open to private enterprise, but its international legal framework rests on States. Under Article VI of the Outer Space Treaty, States bear international responsibility for their national activities in space, including those carried out by private companies. Private activities require authorization and continuing supervision by the appropriate State.

For an Israeli company, the legal analysis therefore does not end with a launch services contract. It must address which State is responsible for the activity, what authorizations are required and how supervision will work. International responsibility for an activity and liability to compensate for damage are also distinct concepts: they may depend on different connections to the States involved. Launching abroad does not bring the legal discussion to an end – a satellite of an Israeli company launched by a foreign provider may still engage Israel’s international responsibility.

In future articles, we will explore responsibility for private activities, damage caused by space objects and the debate over resource use. Our aim is to connect the compelling stories of space exploration with the practical questions facing companies and entrepreneurs in Israel.

At Or-Hof Law, we see space law as part of the intersection of law, technology and business – areas at the heart of our practice. In our view, legal questions are not a footnote to a technological mission. They are part of planning operations, understanding risks and building partnerships.

Sputnik showed how silence can help shape a legal rule. The race to the Moon poses a different question: can we agree on the rules before we reach the same crater?

Planning a space-related venture? We would welcome a conversation about the legal questions it raises.

Or-Hof Law | Space Law

Dan Or-Hof teaches the Space Law course at Reichman University’s Harry Radzyner Law School. In this article, drawing on his lecture on international space law, we explore a field where questions of sovereignty, ownership and responsibility reach far beyond Earth.

On 4 October 1957, a small satellite entered orbit around Earth – and challenged not only the balance of power between nations, but also the law. Sputnik 1 passed over countries without seeking permission. On the ground, borders were clear. Above them, a new reality was unfolding, without a dedicated treaty to govern it.

The most fascinating part of the story is what did not happen: no State protested that orbital overflight violated its sovereignty. That silence became a milestone in the emergence of the customary rule allowing satellites to orbit above national territories. Sometimes, a new legal rule begins not with a signature, but with the absence of an objection.

A Flag on the Moon Is Not a Title Deed

In July 1969, American astronauts planted a flag on the Moon. The image became a historic symbol, but not a certificate of ownership. Later that year, Congress made clear in legislation that the flag was a gesture of national pride, not a declaration of sovereignty.

The distinction rests on the 1967 Outer Space Treaty. Article II prohibits national appropriation of outer space, including the Moon and other celestial bodies, by claims of sovereignty, use, occupation or any other means. Put simply, arriving first does not give a State ownership.

What about a private individual? Since 1980, American entrepreneur Dennis Hope has sold “plots” on the Moon, arguing that the prohibition applies to States, not individuals. The prevailing legal view rejects that argument: private title requires recognition and enforcement, and a State Who cannot circumvent the prohibition on appropriation by recognizing a private claim to lunar territory. An impressive certificate does not turn lunar land into legally recognized property.

If No One Owns the Moon, Who Owns Its Resources?

This is where the story becomes more complicated. The question is no longer just who may plant a flag, but whether a company can extract lunar water ice and own what it extracts. Is mining a permitted use – or prohibited appropriation?

One approach borrows an analogy from the sea: you cannot own the high seas, but you can own the fish you catch. Several States have adopted national laws, including the United States (2015), Luxembourg (2017), the UAE (2019) and Japan (2021), distinguishing ownership of a celestial body from ownership of an extracted resource. The Artemis Accords, a set of non-binding political commitments that Israel signed in January 2022, also affirm that extracting and using space resources does not inherently constitute national appropriation. This is an important position in the debate, not a universally agreed legal solution.

In December 2020, NASA gave this question a tangible form: it contracted with companies to purchase small quantities of material to be collected on the Moon. One contract set a symbolic price of just one US dollar. The significance lay not in the price, but in the legal proposition: transferring ownership of a resource collected on the Moon without first bringing it back to Earth.

The Space Race Is Also a Race to Shape the Rules

Near the Moon’s south pole, permanently shadowed craters may contain water ice. When several actors seek to operate at the same desirable sites, freedom of access can collide with the need to protect existing operations.

Imagine, by way of illustration, two operators seeking to work near the same crater: one needs to land equipment, while the other fears the landing will damage its facilities. Must the first keep its distance? Who decides how far away, and for how long? This hypothetical captures the tension behind the Artemis Accords’ “safety zones”: coordination to prevent harmful interference on the one hand, and concern that protecting operations could effectively exclude others from a valuable site on the other.

Article IX of the Outer Space Treaty requires due regard for the corresponding interests of other States and includes obligations concerning harmful contamination and prior consultation where a State has reason to believe its activity may cause potentially harmful interference. It does not give another State a veto. The challenge is turning broad principles into workable rules – even when the participants are competitors.

Why This Matters to Israeli Companies

Space is open to private enterprise, but its international legal framework rests on States. Under Article VI of the Outer Space Treaty, States bear international responsibility for their national activities in space, including those carried out by private companies. Private activities require authorization and continuing supervision by the appropriate State.

For an Israeli company, the legal analysis therefore does not end with a launch services contract. It must address which State is responsible for the activity, what authorizations are required and how supervision will work. International responsibility for an activity and liability to compensate for damage are also distinct concepts: they may depend on different connections to the States involved. Launching abroad does not bring the legal discussion to an end – a satellite of an Israeli company launched by a foreign provider may still engage Israel’s international responsibility.

At Or-Hof Law, we see space law as part of the intersection of law, technology and business – areas at the heart of our practice. In our view, legal questions are not a footnote to a technological mission. They are part of planning operations, understanding risks and building partnerships.

In future articles, we will explore responsibility for private activities, damage caused by space objects and the debate over resource use. Our aim is to connect the compelling stories of space exploration with the practical questions facing companies and entrepreneurs in Israel.

Sputnik showed how silence can help shape a legal rule. The race to the Moon poses a different question: can we agree on the rules before we reach the same crater?

Planning a space-related venture? We would welcome a conversation about the legal questions it raises.

Read More about our activity

For Further ReadingThe Artemis Accords -NASA: https://www.nasa.gov/artemis-accords